The Guardian reports on loud sonar's effects on whales. No doubt, elephant seals are also affected. This was the argument against PG&E's seismic tests last year. Thanks for the scientific data to support the reasonable assumption that animals that depend on sound will be harmed by explosive blasts.
Whales flee from the loud
military
sonar used by navies to hunt submarines, new research has proven for
the first time. The studies provide a missing link in the puzzle that
has connected naval exercises around the world to unusual mass
strandings of whales and dolphins.
Beaked whales, the most common casualty of the strandings, were
shown to be highly sensitive to sonar. But the research also
revealed unexpectedly that blue whales, the largest
animals
on Earth and whose population has plummeted by 95% in the last century,
also abandoned feeding and swam rapidly away from sonar noise.
The
strong response observed in the beaked whales occurred at noise levels
well below those allowed for US navy exercises. "This result has to be
taken into consideration by regulators and those planning naval
exercises," said Stacy DeRuiter, at the University of St Andrews in
Scotland, who led one of the teams.
"For whales and dolphins,
listening is as important as seeing is for humans – they communicate,
locate food, and navigate using sound," said Sarah Dolman, at charity
Whale and Dolphin Conservation. "Noise pollution threatens vulnerable
populations, driving them away from areas important to their survival,
and at worst injuring or even causing the deaths of some whales and
dolphins." Dolman said there were no accepted international standards
regarding noise pollution and there was an urgent need to re-evaluate
the environmental impacts of military activities.
The US Navy
part-funded the new studies but said the findings only showed
behavioural responses to sonar, not actual harm. Nonetheless, Kenneth
Hess, a US Navy spokesman, said permit conditions for naval exercises
were reviewed annually and added: "We will evaluate the effectiveness of
our marine mammal protective measures in light of new research
findings."
Unusual mass strandings, where multiple species of whale and dolphin beach at several locations at once, have
soared since the introduction of military sonar
in the 1950s and can be fatal. The strandings occur every year and
major recent events saw up to 15 animals beached in the Canary Islands,
the Bahamas and Greece. In May, the
naval activity was found to be the most probable cause of the deaths of at least
26 short-beaked common dolphins in Falmouth Bay, Cornwall in June 2008.
Beaked
whales are the most common species affected by unusual mass strandings,
perhaps because their shy nature makes them more easily scared by
noises that they may interpret as killer whale sounds. Researchers used
suction cups to attach digital devices to Cuvier's beaked whales off the
coast of Southern California to measure the noise they were exposed to
and their response.
When a simulated military sonar signal was
sounded at 200dB and between 3km and 10km away, the whales initially
stopped feeding and swimming. They then swam rapidly away from the noise
and some performed unusually deep and long dives. "The missing piece of
the puzzle was how whales changed their behaviour and how that led to
mass strandings," said DeRuiter. She added that they also stopped
feeding for 6-7 hours, which is unusual. "If they miss out on food, they
will be less healthy," she said, noting that where populations have
been measured, numbers of Cuvier's beaked whales are declining.
A
second study, also off Southern California, estimated that a blue whale
spooked by the sonar missed out on over a tonne of krill, about a day's
worth of food. "Blue whales rely on large aggregations of dense krill to
sustain their extreme body size, so they continuously dive and feed
throughout the day when high-density prey patches are present," said
Jeremy Goldbogen, at Cascadia Research, a non-profit US research
organisation in Olympia, Washington. "Because of this, we suggest that
sonar-induced disruption of feeding could have significant and
previously undocumented impacts on individual baleen whale fitness and
the health of their populations."
A spokesman for the UK's Royal
Navy said: "The Royal Navy already limits its use of sonar around
whales. We are committed to taking all reasonable and practical measures
to protect the environment and mitigate effects on marine mammals. This
new research will be taken into account in the regular review of MoD
active sonar mitigation procedures."
• This article was amended on 3 July 2013 to clarify the claims made by the US Navy, which part-funded the new studies.